Student safety should be a priority on every school campus, as students cannot be expected to learn in an unsafe environment. However, the “Cornell Seven” case highlights a concern about institutional accountability and whether universities are willing to prioritize student safety over their reputation. Universities are responsible for fairly investigating cases of harm to their students, regardless of the damage it may cause to their image.
A former Cornell student, identified by the alias Jane Doe, filed a civil lawsuit this September alleging that she had been gang raped in 2024 by a group of seven students of the Cornell Chi Phi Fraternity. Doe’s lawsuit alleges that she was pressured into becoming heavily intoxicated before multiple men sexually assaulted her over many hours, leaving her in no position to consent. She also accuses Cornell of negligence in handling the case, alleging that they failed to protect her when they disciplined two of the accused with expulsion, while the other five merely received suspensions, probations, and essay assignments.
According to The Cornell Daily Sun, the assigned reflection paper prompt asked one of the defendants to write about substance use preventative measures and a plan to teach undergraduate students about the overlap of social media and sexual harassment. This prompt not only doesn’t address the crime itself, but suggests substance use was the root of the problem, rather than the alleged rape. The fact that writing an essay is considered an appropriate response to a severe sexual assault is troubling enough, so when even the prompt fails to address the crime, it is apparent that the system does not have the interest of the student at its core.
Unfortunately, these concerns are not only limited to universities, but extend to many high schools around the country. Earlier this year, ProPublica published a series titled “Unfit to Teach,” in which it investigated previous allegations of sexual misconduct involving teachers in California.
According to Propublica, cases of sexual offenders like Jason Agan who were not only not properly investigated by the district but whose alleged crimes were not made public. After being dismissed for allegations of sexual misconduct, Agan found teaching jobs in Sacramento, continuing his crimes there. Instead of hiding misconduct, schools should practice transparency and hold perpetrators accountable, prioritizing students’ well-being over their reputation.
Students should be able to trust educational institutions to keep them safe. However, when allegations of misconduct are not properly investigated, that trust is broken. Students should not need the media to expose issues; they should be able to rely on their schools for justice. Both the Cornell Seven case and incidents of sexual misconduct at high schools around the country show the need for greater accountability from such institutions. The reputation schools fight so desperately to preserve means nothing if the students they are meant to protect are the ones paying the price.
